Skip to Main Content
Blog

CAFC Affirms No Infringement in Spinal-Fusion Patent Dispute

09.15.2026
Page Graphic

Last week, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit issued a decision in Moskowitz Family LLC v. Globus Medical, Inc., No. 2024-1696 (Sept. 11, 2026), affirming the Eastern District of Pennsylvania’s finding of no infringement.

Moskowitz sued Globus in 2019 for infringement of several patents directed to implant systems designed to improve spinal-fusion surgery. Following Markman proceedings construing the term “universal” in the ’913 and ’047 patents, Moskowitz withdrew certain infringement allegations and elected to assert only claims with “universal” in the preamble. Globus sought summary judgment; Moskowitz opposed, arguing the preambles were non-limiting, but conceded it could not prove infringement under the court’s construction. The court held the preambles were limiting and entered summary judgment as to those patents.

The remaining patent, the ’319 patent, proceeded to a jury trial. Globus argued the accused products did not satisfy the “cooperating” requirement of a limitation reciting “a gripper…cooperating with the first handle….” The jury agreed with Globus, and the district court subsequently denied Moskowitz’s motion for JMOL. Moskowitz appealed.

The Federal Circuit affirmed. Regarding the ’913 patent preamble, the Court noted that claim body elements (“the integral vertebral cage” and the first and second integral screw guides) depended on the preamble for antecedent basis. The Court found the preamble furnished “essential meaning” and the specification highlighted the “universal” aspect of the claimed invention. The Court reached a similar conclusion for the ’047 patent, rejecting Moskowitz’s argument that “universal” was merely a statement of intended use. The Court also rejected Moskowitz’s challenge to the construction of “universal,” agreeing with the district court’s specification analysis and rejecting the argument that the district court improperly required a physically impossible “one-size-fits-all” approach.

Turning to the ’319 patent, the Court found substantial evidence, including testimony from Globus’s expert, on which the jury could have relied. The Court noted Moskowitz had declined to seek construction of “cooperating,” and the jury instructions reflected the parties’ agreed plain-and-ordinary-meaning use. The Court also observed that Moskowitz’s expert provided only limited testimony the jury could have found not credible, and therefore affirmed denial of the JMOL motion.