Skip to Main Content
Blog

CAFC Vacates Infringement and Validity Judgments Over Claim Construction Errors

09.29.2026
Page Graphic

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit recently issued a precedential opinion in NCS Multistage Inc. v. Nine Energy Service, Inc., No. 2025-1000 (Sept. 14, 2026), vacating the Western District of Texas’s judgment that Nine infringed and failed to invalidate claims of U.S. Patent No. 10,465,445 ("the '445 patent").

The '445 patent relates to a rupture-disc float tool used in oil and gas operations. A jury found Nine directly infringed claims 28 and 29 and induced infringement of claims 36, 39, 50–52, and 55–57, that the claims were not invalid, and awarded damages. The district court denied Nine's post-trial motions, and Nine appealed.

The Federal Circuit addressed three claim construction disputes and a prior art issue. First, the Court held that "internal diameter" cannot mean both an inner surface and a measured diameter. Applying the presumption of consistent meaning throughout the claims, the Court concluded the plain meaning is a “measured diameter.” A fact dispute remained regarding where the rupture disc attaches on the accused BreakThru devices, so the Court vacated and remanded rather than reversing.

Second, the Court held that "casing string" is not limited to pipe "customarily ≥ 4.5 inches in outer diameter”—nothing in the intrinsic record imposes a size limitation. This error was prejudicial, “put[ting] a thumb on the scale” by letting NCS exclude prior art simply because it was under 4.5 inches.

Third, applying Sanho Corp. v. Kaijet Technology International Ltd. (2024), the Court held that NCS's private 2012 sale of its AirLock device to Tundra was not a “public disclosure” under 35 U.S.C. § 102(b)(1)(B). Under Sanho, a commercial sale does not necessarily make an invention “available to the public.” Here, the AirLock was sold privately to one party and delivered in sealed tubes, with no wide distribution. Consequently, TCO's later sale of its TDP-PO tool to Apache qualified as prior art, and the Court vacated the no-invalidity judgment.

Finally, the Court found no abuse of discretion in striking late-disclosed evidence, given Nine’s years-long delay in subpoenaing TCO. Having vacated the infringement and validity judgments, the Court also vacated damages and remanded for a new trial.